Conservation Biology, BIOE 440 and BIOE 521


Class Hours & Location: MWF 12:00- 12:50, Cheever Hall, Room 213

 

Instructor: Dr Scott Creel 302 Lewis Hall, Phone: 994-7033. Email: screel@montana.edu

 

Office Hours: TH 10-12, W 2-3.  I am always happy to answer questions immediately after class, by email, or by appointment at other times.

 

Text: The reading will be a mix of journal articles with textbook chapters for background. Required reading (journal articles, book chapters) that does not come from the textbook will be linked from this web page (links in the syllabus below).  The textbook is Conservation of Wildlife Populations, by L.S. Mills  (Blackwell Publishing, ISBN 1-4051-2146-7).  We are using the first edition (a second edition is advertised  but not available yet, so don't accidentally order it).


Software:
Graduate students
:   We will use R to construct some simple mathematical models of population dynamics, to model extinction risk.  As much as possible, I want to focus on the population biology, rather than the programming & syntax, but it is also generally  useful to become familiar with R, because it is widely used for statistical analysis and mathematical modelling in ecology.  The R models of population dynamics will be independent study, parallel to in class lectures.  R is installed in the MSU student computer labs (Reid Hall, Roberts Hall) and on the machines in Lewis 407.  If you want to run it on your own machine, you can download it from the Comprehensive R Archive Network, CRAN.  If you do not already know R from statistics classes at MSU, you should make yourself familiar with the basics of R by looking at "An Introduction to R", under the manuals link at the CRAN site.  Do this before we get to the section of the course on demography and population dynamics. There are also many good books available, such as Zuur, Ieno & Meester's "A beginner's guide to R".   "The R Book", by Crawley is a comprehensive manual, well worth the investment for a new graduate student.

Undergraduates:  We'll use MS Excel, to model extinction risk.  I am assuming that you have some basic experience with Excel.  If not, you should take some time during the early part of the semester to familiarize yourself with entering data, using formulas, copying and pasting in a way that maintains correct cell references (that is, understanding the use of "$" in cell references), and making graphs.


For demography and PVA, POPULUS has a nice module to supplement the book.  Download here and follow the installation instructions.  Populus is a menu-driven program that shows graphical output from common models in population biology, from Don Alstad at the University of Minnesota.

Grading:

BIOE 440: Two in class exams (25% each, one in finals week), a paper (20%), one take home test (15%), and an in class debate (15%).  The take home test will be to construct a model to estimate a species' extinction risk from demographic data, using Excel and POPTOOLS.
BIOE 521:  Two in class exams (25% each, one in finals week), a paper (20%), one take home test (15%) and an in-class debate (15%).  The take home test will be to construct a model to estimate a species' extinction risk from demographic data, using R.  The paper has extra requirements for graduate students (details below). 


Research Paper Instructions  Note that the instructions differ for BIOE 440 and 521.    Although the paper is not due until later in the semester, you should pick a topic and begin looking for articles with plenty of lead time.


Course Outline:  

 

We will cover some or all of the following major subjects, depending on time:


Human population growth - the 'arms race' between growth rates and carrying capacity

Biodiversity   methods of measurement, broad patterns, and processes that maintain diversity
Extinction
– recent and historical rates and causes of extinction and population decline.
Global warming and its consequences for ecology and conservation.  This will  focus primarily on understanding the carbon cycle and atmospheric processes, how anthropogenic influences are altering these, and the consequences for ecological processes (mainly the distribution and abundance of species).  We'll address ecological economics to some extent

Speciation and the ESA – the process generating diversity, and tricky interactions between phylogeny, taxonomy and law.

Genetic issues in conservation – inbreeding, hybridization, and the use of molecular genetic tools in conservation.
Extinction risk  demography, population dynamics, stochasticity and PVA
Predation and Harvesting – population dynamics with interspecific interactions, discounting, externalities, publicly held goods

Community-level approaches – Diversity and Stability

Landscape approaches – hotspots, gap analysis


These fall into five main sections:  general issues, human impacts, genetic and evolutionary approaches, single-species approaches, and multi-species or location-based approaches.

 

CWP Mills, Conservation of Wildlife Populations.  


Topic 1
Conservation Biology & Human population growth - a race between N & K.
CWP CH 1

Cohen 1995.  Population growth and the earth's carrying capacity.  Science 269: 341-346. pdf
(optional reading) Arrow et al 1995.  Economic growth, carrying capacity and the environment.  Science 268: 520-521 pdf


Topic 2
Biodiversity: how many species, what patterns?  Extinction rates and causes. (see last couple of pages)
CWP CH 13
Pimm et al. 1995.  The future of biodiversity.  Science 269: 347-350.  pdf
(optional reading)  Balmford et al. 2002.  Economic reasons for conserving wild nature. Science 297: 950-953. pdf

September 13 update: Coincidentally, just after we discussed this in class, a new monkey species was discovered in DR Congo!  The Lesula monkey joins the recently discovered Yoda bat (2009, New Guinea) and  cowboy frog (2010, Suriname), among others.

Topic 3
Global warming and its implications for conservation.  Optional reading:  Archer, D (2007).  Global warming: understanding the forecast. Blackwell publishing, Malden, MA. (ISBN 978-1-4051-4039-3).  This is an excellent and well-written introductory textbook that goes though global warming starting with the basic chemistry and physics, and proceeding  to the atmospheric science.
Part 1: Overview
Kaufman et al. 2009.  Recent warming reverses long term arctic cooling.  Science 325: 1236-1239.  pdf
NASA data on spatial and temporal variation in 5-year temperature anomaly

Part 2: How does it work?  The basics - blackbody radiation and greenhouse gasses.
Part 3:  How does it work?  Simple models of the atmosphere - the layer model.
Part 4:  Refining the models.  The lapse rate.  Feedbacks.  Global Circulation Models.
Part 5Back to the causes: economic development, energy consumption and the environment (SKIP THIS FOR FALL 2012)
Pacala & Socolow 2004.  Stabilization wedges: solving the climate problem for the next 50 years with existing technologies.  Science 305: 968-972.
Carbon emissions data 1959 - 2010 (International Energy Agency)
& BAU projections (Pacala & Sokolow)


CO2 capture and sequestration strategies: overview of existing technologies and limitations.
Two case studies:
Weyburn oil field project: sequestration of supercritical CO2 (byproduct of synfuel production) used in enhanced recovery of oilfied past  its Hubbert peak.
Sleipner natural gas project: sequestration of CO2 byproduct from methane wells in North Sea.


Part 6:  Biological responses:
Primary: distribution, abundance, phenology
Secondary: change in community structure - new interspecific interactions, different phenological changes at different trophic levels - food web disruptions).

Parmesan & Yohe 2003.  A globally coherent fingerprint of climate change impacts across natural systems.  Nature 421: 37-42.  (review and synthesis of observed responses)
Additional examples of observed responses:
   Fitter & Fitter 2002 - plant phenology (see fig 1 & table 1)
   Diamond et al 2011 - butterfly phenology

Thomas et al. 2004.  Extinction risk from climate change,  Nature 427: 145-148. (review of projections using climate envelope modelling and SA curves)
Reusch et al.  2102. Projected Climate-Induced Habitat Loss for Salmonids in the John Day River Network, Oregon, U.S.A. Conservation Biology 26:873-882. (an excellent example of the climate envelope modellig approach
for three species )
Additional examples of projections using the climate envelope approach:
   Wolverine climate envelope model
   Marine fish - interaction of climate effects on body size and extinction risk, accounting for changes in distribution

Study guide for Exam 1 (We have not done the genetics part of this yet, so only use the portion on human population growth and numbers of species, extinction rates).
Study guide for climate change portion of Exam 1

Exam 1  Short answer and essay. 
Expect one set of questions for each of three areas: (1)  the number of species, extinction rates, patterns of diversity & rarity  (2) human population growth, (3) climate change.

Topic  4

CWP CH 3
Species and The Endangered Species Act. pdf

Classification methods

DPS policy from Federal Register

O'Brien & Mayr Bureaucratic mischief: recognizing endangered species and subspecies. Science 251:1187-1189  pdf

Identifying a DPS/ESU in practice - Waples, Moritz, Crandall

Topic 5

Hybridization
Hedrick PW 2001.  Conservation genetics: where are we now?  Trends Ecol. Evol. 11: 629-636. pdf (optional reading)

Allendorf et al. 2001.  The problems with hybrids: setting conservation guidelines.  Trends Ecol Evol. 16:613-622. pdf

Hybridization – including red wolf case study



Topic 6

Inbreeding

CWP CH 9
F - statististics

Keller & Waller 2002.  Inbreeding effects in wild populations.  Trends Ecol Evol 17: 230-241.

Inbreeding – cheetah case study

Caro & Laurensen 1994.  Ecological and genetic factors in conservation: a cautionary tale.  Science 263:485-486.

Homework: inbreeding coefficients and F statistics


Topic 7

CWP CH 4,5,6

PVA and extinction risk in small populations

Population viability analysis  - introduction


BIOL 521:Computer Lab:  Review "An Introduction to R" under the manuals link at CRAN


Count-Based PVA



Excel count-based PVA
for grizzly bear data


BIOL 521: A simple count based PVA - exponential and density-dependent population growth models with stochasticity for Yellowstone grizzly bear data. 



Sampling error and apparent density dependence  - Excel spreadsheet illustrating the 'induced correlation' between population growth rate and N when one samples from a normal distribution of N (as opposed to a normal distribution of growth rates).  Illustrates why sampling error in estimates of population size produces a pattern that looks exactly like density dependent population growth.  


PVA – basic demography

CWP CH 7

PVA –  population growth models &  Leslie matrix projection of population growth


Populus has a good module on age-structured growth  (under Single species dynamics).  With three tabs at the bottom, you can edit a life table, view the changes in the llife cycle diagram and in the Leslie matrix. To the right you can plot the associated lx curves, mx curves, age distributions, etc.  A good learning tool to soldify your grasp on the ways that a life table and a Leslie matrix incorporate the information from a life cycle diagram.


Leslie matrix notes.


Leslie calculator - a tool to understand deterministic age-structure growth  This is a GREAT tool to understand stable age distributions. Project for several time steps with no changes to the Leslie matrix.  Then modify the Leslie matrix and repeat the exercise.  Basic Leslie matrix Excel spreadsheet - understanding deterministic population projections. Another tool to understand Leslie projections, using a simple spreadsheet approach  to implement the projections. Allows you to fiddle with adding a harvest, but you can ignore that for now.


BIOL 447: Example EXCEL spreadsheet using stochastic Leslie matrix projection to determine the probability of pseudo-extinction.  This implements the projection in two ways, to illustrate good and less-good methods.  There is a pop-up set of notes that explains the functions and formulas that accomplish the necessary steps.

BIOL 521: Computer Lab: Stochastic Leslie matrix  projection v1:  This lab uses the popbio package  to  implement  stochastic projection and estimate extinction risk via the 'multiple matrixes' approach.  That is, at each time step, it resamples from a set of projection matrices (each matrix comes from a single year of observation).

BIOL 521: Computer Lab: Stochastic Leslie matrix  projection v2:  This lab uses the popbio package to implement stochastic projection and by treating the entries in the projection matrix as variables with a defined distribution, mean and variance.


Brook, BW et al. 2000.  Predictive accuracy of population viability analysis in conservation biology.  Nature 404: 385-387. pdf
Coulson et al. 2001.  The use and abuse of population viability analysis.  Trends. Ecol. Evol. 16:219-221.  pdf


EXAM 2 - Take home.  You must work individually on the take home test.  Passed out WED 11/28, due FRI 11/30.
 
BIOL 447 version   
 
BIOL 521 version   



Topic 8

Harvesting & sustainable offtake part 1

CWP  CH 8, 14

Ludwig 2001.  Can we exploit sustainably?  Pp 16-38 in Reynolds, Mace, Redford & Robinson (eds) Conservation of Exploited Species.

Harvesting & sustainable offtake part 2

Harvest economics: stocks and discounting.


Brashares J, et al. 2004.  Bushmeat hunting, wildlife declines and fish supply in West Africa.  Science 306: 1180-1183.


Topic 9
Parasitism & Disease
May R. 1983.  Parasitic infections as regulators of animal populations.  American Scientist 71: 36-45.  Passed out in class.
Haydon, DT et. al. 2006.  Low coverage vaccination strategies for the conservation of endangered species.  Nature 443:692-695.pdf
Hudson et al 1998.  prevention of population cycles by parasite removal.  Science 282: 2256- 2258.  pdf


Topic 10

Community Ecology – diversity and stability at population and community levels

More notes on diversity & stability  
CWP: CH 10

Tilman 1996.  Biodiversity: population vs. ecosystem stability.  Ecology 77:350-363.

Community Ecology – interactions among species and consequences of species loss

Berlow 1999.  Strong effects of weak interactions in ecological communities.  Nature 398:330-334.

Notes on'weak interaction' effect in diversity-stability relationship.

Topic 11

Habitat Fragmentation and IslandBiogeography

Gotelli 1995.  Island Biogeography.  In: A Primer of Ecology, chapter 7, pp 172-195., Sinauer, Sunderland MA.   Passed out in class.

Habitat Fragmentation and Island Biogeography  2

Watling JI & Donelly, AI 2006.  Fragments as islands: a synthesis of faunal responses to habitat patchiness.  Conservation Biology 20:1016-1025.


Topic 12

Landscape Ecology – gap analysis, hotspots and coldspots

Dobson et al. 1997.  Geographic distribution of endangered species in the United States.  Science 275: 550-553.

van Jaarsveld et al. 1998.  Biodiversity assessment and conservation strategies.  Science 279:2106-2108.
Landscape Ecology – gap analysis for Idaho case study (notes are with hotspots & coldspots, above).

Kiester et al. 1996.  Conservation prioritization using GAP data.  Conservation Biology 10:1332-1342
Worm et al. 2005
.  Global patterns of predator diversity in the open oceans.  Science 309: 1365-1369.



EXAM 3 - final exam is on Thursday Dec 13th 6:00 PM in the regular room (Cheever 213).  The final will cover all of the topics relared to genetic approaches, and the material we cover in the last two weeks, after PVA.


Review questions for final exam